Bring Iran Into the Mecca Alliance, and Israel Loses

The only party that loses out in that equation is Israel.

Eldar Mamedov makes the case for a counterintuitive proposal: that Iran should join the Mecca alliance of Turkey, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan. Many observers read that pact as a structure built to deter Iran. Mamedov argues the opposite, that bringing Iran inside would turn it into a formula for regional stability rather than confrontation.

His reasoning runs through the Houthi conflict. If Iran is brought under a broader security umbrella, Mamedov says, it would be incentivized to use its leverage on the Ansarullah movement in Yemen to scale down attacks on Saudi Arabia. At the same time, the arrangement would encourage Saudi Arabia to make a deal with the Houthis and stop bombing them. The result, in his framing, is a situation where everybody wins: the Saudis and the Houthis end their war, and Iran becomes part of a broader regional arrangement. The only party that loses, he argues, is Israel, which is precisely why it makes sense for these countries to come together.

Mamedov grounds the proposal in a shift he sees among Turkey, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan, who increasingly view American unreliability and Israeli hegemonic ambition as larger threats than anything Iran poses. That realignment, he suggests, opens space for an inclusive structure that includes states that are neither allies nor friends, which he says is the only kind of architecture that can actually deliver collective security. The stakes are direct: a calmer regional order reduces the risk of the kind of escalation that could drag in Armenia, Azerbaijan and the wider neighborhood. Mamedov distills a complex idea into a single sharp thought, that peace built on inclusion would leave Israel’s maximalist strategy with nowhere to go.

Transcript

Eldar Mamedov: So why bringing Iran in would make sense precisely because that would create a kind of regional, inclusive regional structure whereby they no longer have to worry too much about the threat that Iran could pose to any of these countries. and we're talking about Iran's support for the Ansarullah movement for example in Yemen, the Houthis so if Iran is brought into this sort of broader umbrella, security umbrella then Iran would be incentivized also to use its leverage on the Houthis to scale down their attacks on Saudi Arabia but at the same time it would also encourage Saudi Arabia to make a deal with the Houthis and stop bombing them so in the end if that kind of structure can work out then everybody wins the Saudi and the Houthis they stop their war and Iran becomes part of the broader arrangement and the only party that loses out in that equation is Israel precisely the reason why it makes sense for these countries to come together. When it comes to Israel, well, in the future, if Israel changes its policies,