Why Courting Israel Would Be Delusional for Armenia

Why would Israel ever choose Armenia over Azerbaijan?

Eldar Mamedov takes direct aim at a line of thinking he finds both dangerous and delusional: that Armenia should make itself more interesting to Israel. He names Sheila Paylan, who argued in that direction for the Atlantic Council, and he associates the view with experts on the liberal side who support Pashinyan. Then he dismantles the logic with a series of questions.

Why, Mamedov asks, would Israel choose Armenia over Azerbaijan when it already has decades of strategic alliance with Baku? What assets could Armenia possibly offer to displace Azerbaijan as Israel’s main ally in the South Caucasus? And most importantly, what would Armenia actually get in exchange, and what would the costs be? His conclusion is stark: following this advice would bring no geopolitical benefit while destroying Armenia’s relationship with Iran, which he describes as of vital importance and essentially the only friendly neighbor Armenia has in its current predicament.

Asbed then widens the stakes, raising the fear that the Trump Route could become an implicit base for operations against Iran, and recalling Mamedov’s earlier point that Iran no longer observes red lines for any country harboring overt or covert operations against it. This highlights the real weight of the choice. Mamedov ties together several threads of the episode, the centrality of the Armenia-Iran border, the risks of alignment with Israel, and the danger that transit infrastructure could be weaponized. In a crowded and hostile region, there is a clear, pointed argument for Armenia that preserving ties with Tehran should outrank any speculative courtship of Israel.

Transcript

Eldar Mamedov: I know that some Armenian experts, more on the liberal side, more supporting the current Prime Minister Pashinyan, that they were entertaining some notions that Armenia must make itself more interesting to Israel. I'm talking specifically about Sheila Paylan, who wrote an article in that direction for the Atlantic Council. Frankly, I find this line of thinking delusional,

Asbed Bedrossian: Dangerous, yeah.

Eldar Mamedov: because why would Israel, dangerous and delusional, why would Israel choose Armenia over Azerbaijan if it already has decades of this strategic alliance with Azerbaijan, what kind of assets Armenia could offer to displace Azerbaijan as Israel's main ally in the South Caucasus? And most importantly, what will Armenia get in exchange and what are going to be the costs of such alignment? So it would seem to me that following that advice would not accrue any geopolitical benefits to Armenia, but it would definitely destroy Armenia's relationship with Iran, which, as I mentioned, is of vital importance.

Asbed Bedrossian: Yeah, we are also wondering exactly on that issue.