The CSTO Won't Give Armenia an Easy Out

The CSTO suspended Armenia's rights, but it won't kick Armenia out.

Hovik breaks down what the CSTO actually did: it suspended Armenia’s rights within the organization but did not terminate Armenia’s membership. He notes that even harsher measures were floated, including a proposal tied to Belarus to forbid Armenian access to top secret documents, though that step was not used as punishment this time. These remain potential escalation options. His read is that Moscow does not want to hand Armenia an easy exit from the alliance. We call BS on Pashinyan’s posture. He has said Armenia has lost interest in the CSTO and suggested the organization could do Armenia a favor by removing it. But the CSTO’s documents do not specify a mechanism for ejecting a member, and the practical reality is that the alliance would rather keep Armenia frozen in place than let it walk. That keeps Armenia tethered even as it drifts toward the European Union and talks up a possible non-alignment clause in a future constitution.

The suspension of voting rights, the unused leverage over classified materials, and the refusal to end membership all point to a slow, deliberate squeeze rather than a clean break. We connect to the broader thread on Pashinyan’s three planned December trips to Russia, the Eurasian Economic Union meeting on the calendar, and the question of whether Armenia can actually extract itself from Russian-led structures or simply remains stuck between them.

Transcript

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah, well, it seems like the CSTO has not lost interest in Armenia yet completely because they actually did suspend Armenia's rights in the organization, but they did not terminate Armenia's membership. There were even harsher terms proposed by, I think, Lukyanov from Belarus, such as, forbidding any access to top secret documents of the organization by Armenia. And I think that was also not used as a punishment so far. But those are potential escalation options. CSTO documents don't specify a way how countries kicked out or, you know,

Asbed Bedrossian: Mm-hmm.

Hovik Manucharyan: ejected from the organization. But I think it's very clear that Russians and Moscow don't want to give Armenia an easy out from the CSTO.