Who Really Put Rivers on the Agenda

The evidence may be circumstantial, but we're not stupid.

The hosts dig into a single sentence from the Dublin statement between Pashinyan and Aliyev, the line welcoming working groups on the management of transboundary rivers. Hovik argues there is no public sign that cross-border water is a priority for Armenia, which means Azerbaijan put it on the agenda. If Baku raised it, he reasons, Baku intends to use it later, whether as propaganda against the Armenian nuclear power plant at Metsamor or against the mining operations that form the backbone of the economy in Syunik.

Asbed reinforces the case with specifics. Azerbaijan has spent years pressing claims about pollution from Armenia’s mines into rivers flowing toward the Araks, and raised similar complaints at international bodies in the weeks before COP31. The readouts from both governments read much the same, with no confirmation that Pashinyan initiated any of it. His conclusion is blunt: the evidence may be circumstantial, but we are not stupid, this was initiated by Aliyev.

Framing the environment as a shared concern sounds benign, but the hosts show how Baku has repeatedly weaponized environmental claims for geopolitical leverage, including during the Artsakh blockade. Targeting Syunik’s mines would strike at the region’s economic strength, and pressure on Metsamor touches Armenia’s power supply directly. The segment connects to the episode’s recurring worry that Pashinyan lets the scope of negotiations expand into areas where Aliyev holds the advantage, and that Armenians only learn the real terms long after they are agreed. This is a concrete example of how a soft-sounding clause can become a hard instrument of pressure.

Transcript

Hovik Manucharyan: So the fact that this point made it to the statement, it means that Azerbaijan is bringing it to the agenda. And if Azerbaijan is bringing it to the agenda, then I think it plans to use it appropriately at a later time, whether it is in its propaganda against the Armenian nuclear power plant or these mining companies. And, you know, when we speak about mining companies, essentially the backbone of the economy in the Syunik region in Armenia are mining operations. So it would be interesting. I mean, to me, that seems like another way of striking at the strength of Syunik and weakening Syunik as a result by Azerbaijan.

Asbed Bedrossian: So, Hovik, the reports from both countries read fairly much the same, and there was no confirmation on the part of Pashinyan that he was the initiator of some of these ideas. Meanwhile, Azerbaijan has spent multiple years pressing claims about, you know, pollution from Armenia's mines into rivers that are flowing into the Araks River, for example, and going down, you know, along the border between Iran and Azerbaijan. Even a couple of weeks ago, well, actually in the last month or so before COP31 in Armenia, they were complaining about some of these things at international bodies. So to me, it's quite clear. The evidence may be circumstantial, but we're not stupid.