Deaths in Pretrial Detention: Not Deaths, Murder

You used the word deaths. I'll say murder.

After Asbed reports that Strong Armenia’s candidate for Stepanavan mayor, Arsen Gevorgyan, died at Nubarashen on November 10 while held in pretrial detention since late October, Hovik refuses the softer language. He says he will be more forward and call it murder. His argument is direct: there was no indication the man had poor health, he was relatively young, and if the state arrests someone, puts them in pretrial detention, and they die, the responsibility lies with the state whether through poisoning or neglect.

The moment is powerful because it reframes a news item as an accusation with a clear line of responsibility. Hovik questions the use of pretrial detention in the first place, noting the case rested on an allegation of campaign bribery he expects to be proven false in court. Asbed agrees the man should never have been in pretrial detention, calling it Pashinyan’s purgatory where cases never move. The exchange channels a broader human rights concern about how opposition figures are treated in Armenia’s penitentiary system.

This is a grim pattern we trace through the episode, including the earlier deaths of Mher Yeghiazaryan, opposition activist Armen Grigoryan, Armen Hovhannisyan and more. The International Observatory for Democracy in Armenia (IODA) called Gevorgyan’s death a predictable consequence of appalling prison conditions. For viewers following political prisoners and human rights in Armenia, this needs almost no setup, the charge is hard to ignore. All that the audience needs to do is track the treatment of the opposition under Civil Contract.

Transcript

Hovik Manucharyan: Well, I mean, you used the term deaths. I'm going to be more forward and say murder because this is murder.

Asbed Bedrossian: Yeah, yeah.

Hovik Manucharyan: First of all, I'm not even sure if, you know, he died of health issues because, you definitely I think there's neglect involved. but I don't know what is the reason to arrest someone and put them in pretrial detention

Asbed Bedrossian: Mmh.

Hovik Manucharyan: to begin with. And if you're doing that, and there was no indication that this person had bad health, and he was very young relatively speaking, so he's mistreated and he dies, then it's on you. I mean, you're responsible. And I don't care whether you poisoned him directly or it was neglect. the terrorist events in 2016 happened, there was this guy who brought