Rubinyan Dodges Question on Tigranashen Surrender
Ishkhan Saghatelyan asks a simple question: will the government guarantee it won't surrender Tigranashen? Ruben Rubinyan's response is anything but simple.
At the inaugural session of the Ninth National Assembly on August 2, 2026, Armenia Alliance MP Ishkhan Saghatelyan posed a straightforward question to newly elected Civil Contract speaker Ruben Rubinyan: can the government guarantee it will not surrender Tigranashen? The response revealed a carefully constructed evasion that has become characteristic of official government discourse on territorial concessions.
Rubinyan cited Armenia’s internationally recognized territory of exactly 29,743 square kilometers as a red line, but when pressed directly on whether Tigranashen falls within that figure, he pivoted to bureaucratic language about demarcation and “territorial optimization.” This linguistic maneuver introduced a new concept: the idea that even within Armenia’s officially recognized borders, certain “optimizations” might be acceptable if approved by the demarcation commission and subsequently ratified by referendum.
The strategic importance of Tigranashen cannot be overstated. Located on Armenia’s critical north-south transportation artery on the western side, losing it would create severe strategic vulnerabilities and sever Armenia’s ability to defend and supply its southern Syunik province. The fact that the government cannot or will not simply confirm Tigranashen’s inclusion in its stated territorial figure suggests that discussions over its status are actively underway. Saghatelyan’s repeated attempts to extract a clear answer, and Rubinyan’s consistent deflection, underscore the gap between official public statements and actual negotiating positions in the ongoing demarcation process.
Transcript
Asbed Bedrossian: He asked, can you declare and guarantee that during your term in power, under no circumstance and under no pretext, will you surrender Tigranashen? Here's the response, and it's of course translated to English.
Hovik Manucharyan: Can I just say, for those who don't understand, Tigranashen is on a very critical point between the north and south communications artery of Armenia on the west side, and essentially it would... It would create immense strategic problems if Tigranashen, or as the Azeris actually officially refer to it as Qyarqi, is handed over. So this is one of the most strategic positions that Armenia could give away to Azerbaijan.
Asbed Bedrossian: Okay, so simple question to Ruben Rubinyan, and this is the response. I can guarantee that the internationally recognized territory of Armenia is 29,743 square kilometers, and this is a complete and indisputable red line. I can guarantee that the declared program of the Armenian government, which was approved by the people, is as follows. All those territories that are within internationally recognized borders of Armenia should be under our control and the issue should be resolved within the framework of demarcation. As for other issues, according to the regulations of the demarcation commissions can be resolved differently because the regulations allow for certain optimizations,