Transcript: From Abu Dhabi to Dublin: Europe’s Security and Armenia’s Choices | Ep 603, Nov 15, 2026

Posted on Monday, Nov 16, 2026

Summary

Episode Information

Transcript

Warning: This is a rush transcript generated automatically and may contain errors.

Intro to Week in Review for November 15, 2026

Asbed Bedrossian: Hello everyone and welcome to the Armenian News Network Groong Week in Review for November 15, 2026. Folks, we are honored that you listen to us, that you like our shows, that you are subscribed to our channels, and that is great encouragement for us to continue to bring to you factual news and some of our views as well. And we would also be infinitely grateful if you take the time and consider supporting us with your donations. podcasts.groong.org slash donate and ideally become a sustaining member. You can give once, you can give twice, or you can give monthly.

We can tell you factually that will help. Thanks for listening. Hovik, take us to our first topic.

Abu Dhabi Trilateral: US, Russia, Ukraine

Hovik Manucharyan: there are multiple things going on, both in terms of Armenian politics and world politics, but I think it’s worthwhile to begin with Trump’s latest overture in negotiations with Russia after his in the midterm elections. sent out Witkoff and Kushner to have a new round of negotiations with Russia in Abu Dhabi. But what’s unique about this time, I think, is that for the first time they are admitting that something other than just Ukraine is on the table in terms of negotiations, right? I think Trump or U.S. officials talked about a wider security arrangement outside of Ukraine.

To me, that harkens back to what Russia has been demanding all this time, which is a European, essentially, security framework that can guarantee Russia’s security interests. Because Ukraine was not about Ukraine.

Ukraine was about NATO enlargement. and what was interesting is that Kushner went back to the Europeans and said that yeah, Russia is willing to negotiate with you guys and Europe is actually preparing a negotiations team and it’s going to be the E5 so five countries rather than previously the E3 but Russia has said that they would not directly negotiate with Europe. the question, the big question in the room is whether Europe has a seat at the table in these negotiations or not. And it’s pretty interesting watching everything happen.

But from Russia’s side, they seem to be saying that, no, At the same time, they’re demanding or they’re leaking information that they are, Russian demands go as far as rolling back NATO to 1997 borders. on the Europe side Italy and Poland being tacked on Poland essentially having some serious security concerns about Russia and very strong support of Ukraine and also they added von der Leyen and Costa as part of the negotiation team who are very anti-Russian Not sure with a team like that if they’re sending a signal that not going to negotiate all up in the air in terms of whether this is a serious effort by either side.

And so far to me it seems not. And we yesterday talked with Eldar Mamedov from Quincy Institute and Pugwash Council. He’s also very pessimistic that this latest round of discussions is going to yield anything. What are your thoughts about what’s going on?

Asbed Bedrossian: I didn’t see any immediate binding breakthroughs that happened in this meeting, the trilateral meetings in Abu Dhabi. There were a couple of concrete things that were agreed upon. I think that they agreed for a fairly major prisoner of war swap. I don’t believe that has started yet, but they’re planning to do that.

And then there was a commitment to keep talking. And that always sounds funny to me when they agree to continue talking, because these people go from site to site, first Abu Dhabi, and then they’ll go to Hawaii, and then they’ll go to Paris, and they’ll keep talking. The other things that the more intangible agreements, just like you said, it was kind of interesting that there was a sudden agreement. And this was an agreement that Moscow proposed that the European security architecture needs to be talked about.

And the United States agreed, essentially unilaterally. And Europe was not in the room. And they did agree that Europe needs to come to the room, although Russia doesn’t want that. But to be honest, I don’t think that there is an escape from that.

Europe has actually the funny thing, Hovik, is that Europeans, at least three countries, were in Abu Dhabi in another room having a parallel meeting, but they were not in that room. And I read some reports that they were feeling like if they’re not at the table, well, obviously, we are on the menu here.

Hovik Manucharyan: Mm-hmm.

Asbed Bedrossian: And they’re talking about a security architecture about us, and we’re not even sitting at the table. So eventually, though, I don’t, I just don’t see an alternative, they’re going to have to talk. and I’ve said this for a very long time. The moment was missed in the 90s to bring Russia into the Western security architecture. Maybe they’ll wise up and start talking about it because Russia, at least the Russia that we talked about, St.

Petersburg, Moscow, the Second World War, Russia, etc. This is all part of Europe. So there’s no escape from it. another issue that is a little less tangible than other things is this issue of redrawing borders. I think there was talk about Trump had even suggested that maybe Donbas or the Donetsk area had to be given to Russia and redraw the borders this was flatly rejected by the Ukrainian team.

They, they rejected even talking about it but there was one interesting thing by And he said that if there was a real comprehensive package of security that was presented to the Ukrainian team, obviously that would have to be approved by a national referendum, which kind of tells me, well, maybe there’s something that they would accept. I don’t know. I really don’t know. But that’s where we stand from my perspective.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah. Well, for those who have more interest in this topic, follow our interview with Eldar Mamedov. It will be published soon. But yeah, we talked about this with him as well.

All right. What else is going on, Asbed? What’s Pashinyan doing? I hear he’s been traveling a lot this week.

Asbed Bedrossian: Hovik, yeah, just before the show, we were talking about how Pashinyan has

Hovik Manucharyan: Busy. Busy guy. Thank you.

Asbed Bedrossian: gone from Yerevan to Paris, and then from Paris went to Antalya, from Antalya to Dublin, from Dublin to, he’s now in Cambodia for the Francophonie. We don’t know where he’s going next. It’s like a life of international conferences. In Paris, I think it was the Paris Peace Forum, in Antalya it was COP31, right?

It was the European Political Community Summit that they had. And OK, so maybe we can talk about that, Hovik.

CSTO strips Armenia of voting rights

Hovik Manucharyan: you know, before we jump into Pashinyan’s meeting with Aliyev , I think let’s talk about the wider environment, all these, you know, trips and all these meetings are happening in. first, I mean, let’s talk about the fact that just two weeks ago, Pashinyan once again poked Russia pretty strongly in terms of threatening to join the EU, which, you know we know how it’s going for Ukraine there was a meeting of the CSTO that happened in Russia on

Asbed Bedrossian: That was at the same time as COP31 in Antalya,

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah, yeah.

Asbed Bedrossian: I believe. There were many Russian articles that said basically we’re having a CSTO summit here and Pashinyan has opted to go and hang out with European leaders instead.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah. So there were a number of speculations about what would happen in this summit. For Armenia, Pashinyan has said basically he doesn’t care what happens, you know, and the CSTO could do Armenia a favor by kicking it out because he doesn’t have the balls to leave himself.

Asbed Bedrossian: His terms were that Armenia has lost interest in the CSTO.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah, well, it seems like the CSTO has not lost interest in Armenia yet completely because they actually did suspend Armenia’s rights in the organization, but they did not terminate Armenia’s membership. There were even harsher terms proposed by, I think, Lukyanov from Belarus, such as, forbidding any access to top secret documents of the organization by Armenia. And I think that was also not used as a punishment so far. But those are potential escalation options.

CSTO documents don’t specify a way how countries kicked out or, you know,

Asbed Bedrossian: Mm-hmm.

Hovik Manucharyan: ejected from the organization. But I think it’s very clear that Russians and Moscow don’t want to give Armenia an easy out from the CSTO. Thank you.

Asbed Bedrossian: Well, I think the voting rights issue, the suspension of the voting rights sounds reasonable because if you’re not paying your fees, why should you vote and possibly disrupt the others who are constantly participating in what’s going on in the life of the CSTO? Now, I don’t want to justify the CSTO, but I’m looking at it from their perspective. This sounds reasonable. So first of all, like you said, there is no bylaw that allows for kicking a member out.

But that’s just legalistic. Let’s get past that. The reason why they haven’t kicked them out, I read an article that basically said no government is permanent. And after this Pashinyan government, there might come a government that might review the security posture of the country and say, well, we really do need to be in the CSTO, at which point it would be very difficult to readmit a country that has left.

So it might be just the best situation to just keep it frozen because this government of Pashinyan is not interested in doing anything with them, but there might be a future where a government might.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah, well, this whole discussion about the CSTO is pertinent

Asbed Bedrossian: Thank you.

Hovik Manucharyan: because one of the things that Pashinyan wants to do as part of this new constitution, I think, you know, of course, we keep talking about this Declaration of Independence that is referred to by the current constitution and that basically Pashinyan is on the hook for removing as part of Azerbaijan demands.

And there is, I think, some speculation that the new draft of the constitution that Pashinyan will try to force his way through will also mandate that Armenia is a non-aligned country, meaning that it won’t have any foreign military bases and it won’t be a member of any security alliances. which is interesting and it would be like a dream come true for Aliyev I mean, not that the CSTO has been useful, but I think it’s you need to make it work for you, right? You need to want to make it work for you, and I think that Pashinyan has not

Armen Grigoryan’s views on EU membership

Hovik Manucharyan: but why am I saying this? Is one of the chief architects of Armenia’s foreign policy of velvet coup or whatever it’s called in 2018, Armen Grigoryan had an interesting article that he wrote in MediaLab. So let me just set the stage. Armen Grigoryan was until recently the chair of the, or secretary of the National Security Council in Armenia.

Asbed Bedrossian: Since 2018.

Hovik Manucharyan: And since 2018, yeah, from day one.

Asbed Bedrossian: So eight years on the chair.

Hovik Manucharyan: and he left and there was a lot of speculation because then they gave the job to Alen Simonyan. He wrote an article where he basically criticized those in Armenia who want Armenia to be a member of the EU. And he wrote this very funny Facebook post where he said that the more Armenia wants to get away from Russia, the more it finds in the embrace of Russia. But what is interesting is this guy is basically the architect of Armenia’s foreign policy over the last five years or eight years, including, I would say, Armenia’s flirting with the European Union.

I mean, this is the guy who went to Brussels and met with von der Leyen. And after that, he said, yeah, you know, Armenia should just start eating rice because once Russia cuts Armenia’s grain

Asbed Bedrossian: Heh heh heh.

Hovik Manucharyan: supply, we can just replace it with rice. This is a guy who, with a straight face, said that.

Asbed Bedrossian: Hovik, what did you make of the thesis that he was advancing that instead

Hovik Manucharyan: -funded media in Armenia. Yeah.

Asbed Bedrossian: of seeking EU membership, formal EU membership, Armenia should rather strive to become in closer collaboration with the European Union, which is, well, you and I were not surprised by this, but it caused a lot of dialogue in the country. to the point where Civil Contract members were saying, oh, we were aware of his views. This doesn’t mean that he is not part of the camp. We have diversity of views and it makes us stronger, blah, blah, blah. And other people started wondering, well, is this guy suddenly Armen Grigoryan, I mean?

Is he starting to turn towards the opposition? Is he going to join some group? Talk about this for a moment.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah, definitely don’t count on Armen Grigoryan joining the opposition. He’s one of the OGs and one of the, I think, foreign assets in Armenia, if there could ever be a term for it. But I think he was, I think he’s there playing an interesting game where he is now to sort of pull back a little bit Armenia’s EU ambitions. but at the same time he’s everything to push Armenia out of the EAEU and of course the CSTO. And his tack, you know, he gave an interview to CivilNet where he basically reinforced this, you know, non-aligned status.

So honestly, I don’t buy any of this. They have serious differing opinions on anything. I think they’re just playing different parts, different roles. And Armenia’s role now is to walk back like Armenia’s promises, which is going to be difficult. and

Asbed Bedrossian: Well, interestingly enough, for the first time,

Hovik Manucharyan: yeah

Asbed Bedrossian: we actually heard a timeline from Pashinyan. First of all, he said that Armenia should be applying for EU membership sometime in the 2027-2028 timeframe. And then I think it was just a couple of days ago, Friday, when he said that he sees Armenia as an EU member in 20 years, 2048,

Pashinyan to visit Russia 3 times in December

Hovik Manucharyan: But Pashinyan also said that he plans to visit Russia three times in December. And I think one of those is the Eurasian Economic Union meeting. He’s going to be in Russia on December 3rd, 11th and 22nd. And I think the meeting on December 3rd is going to be when he meets with Putin . and finally have that heart-to-heart meeting with everything laid out on the table.

Asbed Bedrossian: I sure hope his chief of protocol has it right this time so that he knows which guy is president of which country.

Hovik Manucharyan: those are all the things that are going on in terms of Armenia’s dance between the EU and Russia. So, within that background, let’s talk about Armenia’s or Pashinyan’s trips, right?

Asbed Bedrossian: So he went to Paris and there was this conference called the Paris Peace Forum. And then he flew to Antalya and that was for COP31. He had some meetings with Aliyev. with Erdoğan and he had a meeting with Pezeshkian. And from there, he flew to Dublin for the European Political Community Summit. and that’s where he met Aliyev.

And now he’s in Cambodia for Francophonie.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah. Yeah. So let’s talk about it. It’s fun to be a grifter and travel on foreign dimes, especially when you’re selling out your country.

Asbed Bedrossian: Let me tell you, Hovik, do you remember when I said last week,

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah. It seems like a lot of people.

Asbed Bedrossian: it’s like the cabinet members all get sent to Europe for these five-star hotels, and the opposition gets sent to jail, and now they get sent to jail to die.

Hovik Manucharyan: Asbed, let’s go directly to Dublin, the European Political Community.

Dublin EPC Summit: Pashinyan & Aliyev meet

Hovik Manucharyan: This is the forum where Armenia sold out Artsakh, where Pashinyan sold out Artsakh by recognizing as part of Azerbaijan. as hard as it is for me to say that, but it’s also part of this Brussels process, right, where Macron and Charles Michel essentially convinced Pashinyan to do this, and there was a series of meetings. So this is another meeting in that series, and Aliyev and Pashinyan, of course, met this time in Dublin, and they signed another statement. normally the public finds out about what really was discussed or what was conceded later as they begin implementing

Asbed Bedrossian: Mm-hmm.

Hovik Manucharyan: but only eye-catching part of this statement between Armenia and Azerbaijan Aliyev and Pashinyan, was this one sentence where they said the leaders emphasized the importance of environmental and transboundary water cooperation and welcomed the establishment of working groups on the management of transboundary rivers.

Asbed Bedrossian: Mm-hmm.

Hovik Manucharyan: know how I think with all these COP conferences, it has become fashionable to talk about the environment. And Baku just loves using the environment for geopolitical, you know, its geopolitical goals. if you look at the state of the Caspian Sea and all the oil rigs there, it’s a dump. But no one cares about that. But they invite someone like Jeffrey Sachs to come and give speeches at COP summits. very capable of using these environments for PR.

But I think this is a potentially very dangerous thing because but we know that Azerbaijan for many years has been using environmental claims to target mining sector in Armenia and Armenian energy sector. For instance, they keep complaining about the danger of the Armenian nuclear power plant, and they also about the danger of Armenian mines in polluting rivers so in fact that was one of the things that they

Asbed Bedrossian: Mmh.

Hovik Manucharyan: when they actually blocked the Lachin Corridor during the Artsakh blockade in 2023 that’s what they they sent a letter to Pashinyan complaining about rivers on the border.

Asbed Bedrossian: Well, Hovik, it always concerns me when I hear stuff like this, because could be priorities, but these are probably priorities 10 through 20, while we haven’t taken care of priorities 1 through 10. Any reasonable negotiator would look at these issues and would say, okay, if you’re interested in talking about rivers and pollution and whatever you want to talk about, we’ll talk about them in the next phase. phase, let’s discuss this and this and this, which because we’re already discussing those, let’s not expand the scope and, and, you know, find frou-frou stuff to, to talk about. So the question is, what has already been decided?

Who authorized it? When are we going to see terms of these things? They welcome the working groups. Do you know that these working groups were set up, who’s in it?

I have a lot of questions about these things, and I’m a little alarmed that this guy, Pashinyan, goes to these negotiations, and suddenly the scope of the negotiations, the so-called peace negotiations, expand to all these areas that Aliyev is a lot smarter to use as leverage on Armenia

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah.

Asbed Bedrossian: and to expand the maximalist demands.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah, and of course, I haven’t seen any public

Asbed Bedrossian: That’s what I’m afraid of.

Hovik Manucharyan: indication that this cross-border water issue is of any importance to Armenia. I mean, maybe from the perspective that Azerbaijan is stealing a lot of the, or rerouting Armenia’s water sources,

Asbed Bedrossian: Mmh.

Hovik Manucharyan: but I don’t think Armenia would be the initiator of these discussions.

Asbed Bedrossian: It’s very unlikely.

Hovik Manucharyan: So the fact that this point made it to the statement, it means that Azerbaijan is bringing it to the agenda. And if Azerbaijan is bringing it to the agenda, then I think it plans to use it appropriately at a later time, whether it is in its propaganda against the Armenian nuclear power plant or these mining companies. And, you know, when we speak about mining companies, essentially the backbone of the economy in the Syunik region in Armenia are mining operations. So it would be interesting.

I mean, to me, that seems like another way of striking at the strength of Syunik and weakening Syunik as a result by Azerbaijan.

Asbed Bedrossian: So, Hovik, the reports from both countries read fairly much the same, and there was no confirmation on the part of Pashinyan that he was the initiator of some of these ideas. Meanwhile, Azerbaijan has spent multiple years pressing claims about, you know, pollution from Armenia’s mines into rivers that are flowing into the Araks River, for example, and going down, you know, along the border between Iran and Azerbaijan. Even a couple of weeks ago, well, actually in the last month or so before COP31 in Armenia, they were complaining about some of these things at international bodies. So to me, it’s quite clear.

The evidence may be circumstantial, but we’re not stupid.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah.

Asbed Bedrossian: This was initiated by Aliyev. It wasn’t Armenian.

Hovik Manucharyan: Exactly. And I guess we have to wait more. And as I said, normally these things happen. Pashinyan concedes something.

And then months or years later, we figure out what it was when they start implementing and slowly letting in the Armenian public. So unfortunately, that is the geopolitical state that Armenia is in under Pashinyan.

Asbed Bedrossian: Yeah.

Hovik Manucharyan: And Pashinyan is willingly driving Armenia through.

Asbed Bedrossian: And the thing is, if we start digging deeper and deeper into the research, you can see that there are some issues with pollution, not just in Armenia, but of course in Azerbaijan also. But right now, when these complaints are being lodged against Armenia, all of it is relying on data that Azerbaijan has collected and is giving that data to the United Nations and saying, look what we’re finding. And there have been United Nations commissions that come to Armenia, but they don’t even collect their own data.

They just look at the situation and they look at the report from Aliyev and that’s what they see. and that’s what we’ve seen ever since the mines in Artsakh were taken over

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah, exactly.

Asbed Bedrossian: yeah

Hovik Manucharyan: It’s pretty much within the MO of Azerbaijan. I’m quickly reminded about how Artsakh or how Aliyev was able to bribe European parliamentarians to talk about Armenia,

Asbed Bedrossian: German parliamentarians, I remember that.

Hovik Manucharyan: German parliamentarians, I remember that. and that suddenly made it into top European agendas and it criticized essentially Armenians for misusing the environment and now it’s all gone and no one talks about it and it was just useful when and then we know all the scandals that happened and who was paid how much for that anyway

Arsen Gevorgyan dies in pretrial detention

Asbed Bedrossian: Hovik, unfortunately, the situation is not very pretty. Hovik, unfortunately, the situation is not very pretty. Strong Armenia’s candidate for Stepanavan mayor, died in Nubarashen. He was in detention since, I think, October 21, about three, four days before the municipal elections.

And on November 10, today is November 16 at this point, so almost a week ago, he died. And he’s only the latest of a string of deaths that have happened in the penitentiary system in Armenia, which is an abysmal system for political opponents.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah.

Asbed Bedrossian: I don’t know what more to say. I mean, there’s a lot more I can say, but what are you thinking?

Hovik Manucharyan: Well, I mean, you used the term deaths. I’m going to be more forward and say murder because this is murder.

Asbed Bedrossian: Yeah, yeah.

Hovik Manucharyan: First of all, I’m not even sure if, you know, he died of health issues because, you definitely I think there’s neglect involved. but I don’t know what is the reason to arrest someone and put them in pretrial detention

Asbed Bedrossian: Mmh.

Hovik Manucharyan: to begin with. And if you’re doing that, and there was no indication that this person had bad health, and he was very young relatively speaking, so he’s mistreated and he dies, then it’s on you. I mean, you’re responsible. And I don’t care whether you poisoned him directly or it was neglect. the terrorist events in 2016 happened, there was this guy who brought bread to the terrorists.

And he crossed the police lines and took some food to the terrorists. He was eventually arrested. They call him Hats Berogh. And until today, the Pashinyan regime is allowing the criminal case around his death to stay open.

And what happened was the police then released him, but within, I think, a day of being released, he died in his own home. And the Pashinyan regime is using that case politically. Meanwhile, they directly caused the detention of this person, and it was pretty clear that it was illegally videotaped campaign staff exchanging money and they alleged that this was bribes and that’s how they arrested. And I’m pretty sure that this will be proven in the courts to be completely false allegations.

Asbed Bedrossian: Well, most of them are just ridiculous allegations.

Hovik Manucharyan: But this person should have been in the jail to begin with.

Asbed Bedrossian: Yeah, exactly. He should have never been in pretrial detention because we know, first of all, that’s just Pashinyan’s purgatory. They never go anywhere. Hovik, I don’t know if you saw the IODA, the International Observatory for Democracy in Armenia.

We’ve talked to Philippe Raffi Kalfayan a couple of times, and his NGO has basically made a couple of statements, and they’re going to have a more comprehensive report in a few days,

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah.

Asbed Bedrossian: just like in three or four days. But they said his death, they’re talking about Arsen Gevorgyan. They said his death is a predictable consequence of the appalling prison conditions in the country prisoners have died in custody since 2025. That’s just last year.

Hovik Manucharyan: 24 prisoners

Asbed Bedrossian: And there’s a lot more. I can read more. Yeah, it’s insane. Absolutely insane.

Hovik Manucharyan: 24 regular prisoners and four political prisoners , I would say, since 2019. And I wanted to mention that at least four, and if not five. One would be Mher Yeghiazaryan. He died in 2019 when he was doing a hunger strike against the regime.

Asbed Bedrossian: He had a 44-day hunger strike.

Hovik Manucharyan: There was a Pashinyan’s euphoria. Yeah. Armen Grigoryan, who was an opposition activist who was simply arrested because I think he called some Armenians, some Armenians like Turks or whatever, and this was the first case where they sort of accused someone of using a hate crime simply for calling, like if I say, are you a Turk? Apparently that’s like a hate crime.

And that was obviously very frivolous, but he died in jail, in the courtroom, actually. And that’s also the responsibility of the Armenian government.

Asbed Bedrossian: Mm-hmm.

Hovik Manucharyan: And then the case of Armen Hovhannisyan in the election campaign in 2026, right? He was an unfortunately mentally ill individual who tore up Pashinyan’s Civil Contract campaign poster, and that’s why they arrested him. And then suddenly he, what was it?

Asbed Bedrossian: He dies.

Hovik Manucharyan: he committed suicide. He was suicided

Asbed Bedrossian: Yeah.

Hovik Manucharyan: or he committed suicide. So,

Asbed Bedrossian: In 2025, we also had Volodya Grigoryan, who was the head of the

Hovik Manucharyan: you know,

Asbed Bedrossian: Parakar community. We’ve had Manvel Grigoryan, you know, General Manvel Grigoryan back in November 2020, I think. And then, you know, something that just really got to me for a very, very long time, that was Srbuhi Mnatsakanyan in April of 2022. this pregnant woman who was crossing the street was hit by Pashinyan’s motorcade and there has been zero accountability on that as well. People keep dying and I don’t know what to say.

Okay, I’m going to stop right there.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah, yeah.

Asbed Bedrossian: You know, I said last week

Hovik Manucharyan: I mean, there’s blood.

Asbed Bedrossian: that these people, we were talking about Arsen, were we talking about Arsen Gevorgyan? I said last week that this person has a family. All of these people who’ve died in prison, they all have families, they all have kids, they all have wives, they all have fathers and mothers, and they spend months and years in pretrial detention. they’re wasting priceless and unrecoverable lifetime for these people for

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah.

Asbed Bedrossian: their families and as you said of course the politics also in the country but of course that’s the point that’s why they are in jail so that the political moment that they represent that threat that they represent to this government passes You know, all of the opposition leaders are in jail. Robert Kocharyan , Karapetyan, Tsarukyan, they’re all in jail right now.

Hovik Manucharyan: It is the responsibility of the government. All of these lives and all of these livelihoods that are being damaged right now is the responsibility of the Pashinyan regime. And there will come a time when they will pay for this in terms of criminal

Asbed Bedrossian: Mm-hmm.

Hovik Manucharyan: punishments. But until then, we have to, I guess, suffer from all this. Essentially, too many people are under this regime’s punishment.

Canada’s SMR reactors over time and over budget. Armenia: stay away!

Asbed Bedrossian: Okay, Hovik, as our last topic, we came across this interesting tweet this past week. Actually, I didn’t just find it. It was a friend who brought it to our attention. Thank you, anonymous friend.

You know who you are. and here’s what it said. It’s a little cryptic. It says, this is, I’m reading the tweet here. It says, OPG update on the BWRX-300.

DNNP Unit 1 is no longer expected to achieve the previously disclosed commercial operation date target of October 2030 or be completed within the previously disclosed estimated cost of $7.7 billion. I’ll give you a hint, that’s 7.7 billion Canadian dollars. We’ll put the link to the tweet in the show notes so that you can look at it. Hovik, what does this mean?

Hovik Manucharyan: I mean, to summarize, this is the Canadian small modular nuclear reactor project, and it is over budget. It is after $7.7 billion of Canadian dollars, they’re still like over budget and over time. and this is a technology that this is one of the technologies that the Armenian government was touting or considering for its you know nuclear next nuclear project and this is just I think another example that these technologies are not mature and are going to cost way more than what we expect in the future.

Asbed Bedrossian: Yeah. The problem is that, just as we’ve said before, there are no SMRs that are deployed and working anywhere in North America, or actually, I’m not even sure, anywhere else. So, once again, we’re not saying that this is not a viable technology. I think it’s just that we’re saying there will be, as you’re deploying these things, there are going to be cost overruns, there are going to be time overruns.

Canada, a rich country like Canada or America will be able to afford those things, whether it’s $7.7 billion or $8.7 billion, a whole bunch of diplomats. I mean, the politicians are going to at each other and complain, and then eventually there will be something, while the citizens of Canada will not even know that there was a delay because there’s enough power. But if you were to do this in Armenia, this thing is a significant percentage of the GDP of Armenia. And second, Armenia’s power plant is on a limited timetable at this point.

It will stop in 2036. And so let’s say you commit to an SMR that’s going to go 300 megawatts or something like that. And you’re hoping that it’s going to come online in 2034, 2035. And sadly, you hear it’s not going to do that.

That means a lot of cold winters. and as we were talking to Vazgen Gabrielyan, an economist a few days ago, at least the 2027 budget is a very optimistic budget. It’s like it’s expecting everything to go right. Any kind of a shock and that budget is not going to be able to withstand it. So what if this thing suddenly goes from 7.7 to 10 billion dollars?

Armenia’s budgets are not going to be able to That’s what we’re saying here. And this exact SMR model is what is believed to have been pitched to Armenia also. So that’s why we’re talking about this. Hovik, let me reiterate.

We are not saying Armenia doesn’t need SMR or needs SMR. We’re saying more power to Armenia. And we really mean gigawatts of power to Armenia, not just 300 megawatts. And don’t be the test bed for this brand new technology.

Go for something that is tested and true and that everybody is working on. Let this technology mature. Let a number of people work the kinks out of it who can afford to work the kinks out of it. And then go for it.

More power to you.

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah, I have nothing to add. Okay, folks, thanks for listening. Once again, this was the Week in Review for the week ending on November 15. Please consider liking, commenting, and sharing so that we get in front of more eyes.

SUPPORT FIERCELY INDEPENDENT GROONG - podcasts.groong.org/donate

Hovik Manucharyan: And we’re the only fiercely independent English language podcast.

Asbed Bedrossian: Fiercely independent, that’s right.

Hovik Manucharyan: I don’t know where that fierce. Yeah, we’re the true fiercely independent media out there. And we’re battling a an army of foreign funded media out there that are, you know, whose whose intentions and whose whose goals are definitely not explainable.

Asbed Bedrossian: So, Hovik, I had, I was at an event in my community here in Glendale last night and met a bunch of people and you know what was encouraging? There were a few very young kids who were there and they said, you’re the guy from the podcast, I listen to you.

Hovik Manucharyan: Nice.

Asbed Bedrossian: and that made me feel so good and these were young kids in school and I felt very

Hovik Manucharyan: Yeah.

Asbed Bedrossian: very good about that so for you all and you again you know who you are thank you for listening and we’ll do our best to keep bringing factual news to you okay

Hovik Manucharyan: And if you can support us, great, podcasts.groong.org.

Asbed Bedrossian: Wonderful.

Hovik Manucharyan: All right, I’m Hovik Manucharyan.

Asbed Bedrossian: And I’m Asbed Bedrossian. We will talk to you next week. Bye-bye.

Hovik Manucharyan: Okay, bye-bye.

Categories: Armenia, Geopolitics, Politics, Transcript
Tags: Armenian News Nagorno Karabakh Civil Contract Syunik CSTO Strong Armenia Masoud Pezeshkian Armen Grigoryan Garegin II Republic Party Ukraine War Armenia-Turkey Relations Armenia-Iran Relations Armenia-EU Relations Abu Dhabi Antalya Armenia-Russia relations December 2026 Armenian Nuclear Power Plant Arsen Gevorgyan Arsen Gevorgyan custody death Artsakh Aftermath Artsakh displaced families housing COP31 COP31 Antalya CSTO voting rights suspension Dublin diplomatic talks European Political Community European Security Housing Metsamor nuclear reactor Modular Nuclear Reactors NATO Pashinyan EU application Pashinyan-Aliyev talks Pretrial Detention shared rivers diplomacy Ukraine peace negotiations Ukraine War Peace Talks Artsakh NKAO